
Sam Smith Regrets Ghosting Tom Petty Over 'Stay With Me' Song Dispute
The pop star maintains they never even heard 'I Won't Back Down' before writing their breakout ballad.
By Dee AlvarezPublished Updated 2 min read
Sam Smith is looking back at one of pop music's most infamous royalty battles with a bit of remorse. The Grammy-winning singer recently opened up about the drama surrounding their massive 2014 hit "Stay With Me," which famously resulted in rock legend Tom Petty securing co-writing credits due to its uncanny resemblance to his 1989 classic "I Won’t Back Down." Appearing on *Alchemy With Anthony Mason*, Smith dished on what went down behind closed doors when the copyright conflict first erupted. The soul star revealed that Petty actually took the high road at the time by sending a personal letter directly to Smith—a gesture Smith now deeply regrets ignoring.
Did Sam Smith steal Tom Petty I Won't Back Down Throughout the entire saga, Smith has held firm on one major detail: the melodic similarities were an absolute accident. Smith continues to maintain that they had never listened to "I Won’t Back Down" prior to writing "Stay With Me," making the sudden legal drama a complete shock. Smith admitted to feeling overwhelmed by the legal machinery involved in the situation. With attorneys driving the high-stakes negotiations, the young pop star froze up and opted not to send a reply back to Petty's handwritten note, a decision that still stings years later.
What did Tom Petty say about Sam Smith Stay
With Me Back in 2015, both sides quietly resolved the dispute without stepping foot inside a courtroom. Petty and his co-writer Jeff Lynne were added to the official credits for "Stay With Me," taking a 12.5% publishing stake in the multi-platinum track. Petty even released a famously gracious public statement at the time, calling the overlap a common hazard in songwriting and insisting he held zero bad blood. Since then, Smith has shown major appreciation for the late rock icon. During a 24-night residency at Warsaw in Brooklyn last year, Smith took the stage to cover Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers' 1987 track "It Will All Work Out," proving that while the original letter went unanswered, the respect was always there.
The photos · 5
More like this

Music
Liz Phair Unveils Behind-the-Scenes Look at Flannel and the Fury Tour With Sleater-Kinney
The indie rock icon offers fans a rare glimpse into life on the road following a joint run with Sleater-Kinney.
Oct 29, 2026

Music
Everything But The Girl Unveil New Album 'Blue Reservoir' After Intimate London Gigs
Tracey Thorn and Ben Watt are back with their 12th studio record and lead track 'Young And Dumb.'
Oct 28, 2026

Music
Unreleased 1978 David Bowie Concert Heading to Arenas as Immersive Spectacle
Director Brett Morgen and the late icon's estate are reviving raw footage from London's Earls Court for a massive 2027 tour.
Oct 27, 2026
Get the pop news brief
One daily email. The biggest celebrity, music and TV stories, no filler.
People also ask
- Did Sam Smith copy Tom Petty's song?
- Sam Smith maintains that the melodic overlap between 'Stay With Me' and 'I Won't Back Down' was completely unintentional and that they had never heard Petty's track before.
- Did Tom Petty sue Sam Smith over Stay With Me?
- No lawsuit was filed. The two parties settled out of court amicably in 2015, giving Tom Petty and Jeff Lynne co-writing credits and royalties.
Reader reaction
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.