John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell in Wild Horse Nine
TV & Film

John Malkovich Shines But Martin McDonagh's Spy Comedy 'Wild Horse Nine' Flatlines With Critics

Even an extraordinary performance from John Malkovich cannot save the director's latest period caper with Sam Rockwell from being dubbed a snooze.

By Rae MitchellPublished Updated 2 min read

Martin McDonagh is back behind the camera, but his newest film isn't securing the unanimous adoration he usually commands. The acclaimed filmmaker behind modern classics like *In Bruges* and *Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri* has unleashed *Wild Horse Nine*, a dark historical spy comedy featuring heavyweights John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell. However, initial critical reviews suggest the picture falls surprisingly flat. The narrative transports viewers to Chile during the tense moments immediately preceding the 1973 fascist coup led by Augusto Pinochet. Rockwell and Malkovich star as Lee and Chris, a pair of CIA agents navigating clandestine operations in South America. The central conflict kicks off when Chris, an aging spy grappling with his legacy, decides to write his personal memoirs, triggering a chaotic series of comic and tragic events. ## Is Wild Horse Nine movie worth watching Despite the high-stakes political backdrop, early word on the film indicates that McDonagh's screenplay relies too heavily on his most familiar storytelling habits. The director has long harbored a fascination with charming criminals and soul-searching hitmen, but reviewers argue this formula is beginning to feel stale. Rather than delivering the razor-sharp cynicism of *In Bruges* or the zany energy of the Coen Brothers' *Burn After Reading*, *Wild Horse Nine* ends up coming across as dry and sluggish. The pacing reportedly drags as the story struggles to balance its heavy historical setting with signature dark comedy. While McDonagh typically excels at making audience members care for flawed, violent figures, critics note that his sympathetic approach feels repetitive this time around, leaving the plot feeling strangely low-energy. ## John Malkovich performance in Wild Horse Nine If there is one overwhelming reason to check out the movie, it is the performance of John Malkovich. Reviewers overwhelmingly praise the Hollywood legend, calling his turn as the veteran secret agent absolute gold. Malkovich brings a magnetic charisma and tragic gravity to Chris, elevating every single scene he dominates. His dynamic alongside Sam Rockwell provides occasional flashes of the brilliant banter fans expect from a McDonagh project. Yet, even with two brilliant leads steering the ship, reviewers warn that the film as a whole feels surprisingly dull. For audiences hoping for another award-season powerhouse from the director, *Wild Horse Nine* stands out as a rare, sleepy stumble—even if Malkovich remains as glorious as ever.

More like this

Get the pop news brief

One daily email. The biggest celebrity, music and TV stories, no filler.

Reader reaction

Loading comments…

People also ask

Who stars in Martin McDonagh's Wild Horse Nine?
The film stars John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell as CIA operatives stationed in Chile during the early 1970s.
What is Wild Horse Nine about?
It follows two CIA agents in 1973 Chile right before a military coup, where an older spy causes chaos by writing a tell-all memoir.
What are critics saying about Wild Horse Nine?
Reviews praise John Malkovich's standout performance but criticize the overall film for being dull and repetitive compared to McDonagh's earlier hits.