Hayley Atwell Trashes Peggy Carter’s Brutal Fate In 'Doctor Strange 2'

Hayley Atwell is not holding back about how Marvel treated her beloved superhero persona. During a recent fan convention, the British actress slammed the brutal death scene handed to Captain Carter in the 2022 blockbuster *Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness*, calling the moment a major misstep for the hero. Speaking to a crowd at London's For the Love of Fantasy & Sci-Fi event, the star reflected on her brief appearance as an alternate universe super-soldier. While fans were initially thrilled to see the live-action debut of Captain Carter, the excitement quickly dissolved when she met a swift and gruesome end. ## Why did Hayley Atwell dislike Captain Carter's death? During her showdown with Elizabeth Olsen's Scarlet Witch, the alternate Peggy Carter attempts to hold the line alongside her fellow Illuminati members. However, the confrontation ends abruptly when Wanda hurls Carter's own vibranium shield right back at her, slicing the heroine in half. Atwell confessed that watching her character get tossed around and eliminated so quickly felt like a disappointment after spending over a decade building the persona. She noted that the violent wrap-up felt underwhelming compared to the rich development the hero had received across various television and film projects. Prior to that live-action stint, Atwell voiced the same variant in the animated Disney+ series *What If...?*, an experience she found far more satisfying. She pointed out that the animated format allowed Captain Carter to showcase genuine strength and lead the narrative, rather than serving as quick fodder for a villain's body count. ## Will Peggy Carter ever come back to Marvel? First joining the Marvel Cinematic Universe in 2011's *Captain America: The First Avenger*, Atwell built a dedicated fanbase that eventually launched two seasons of her standalone series *Agent Carter*. Over the years, she logged cameo appearances across multiple Marvel installments, becoming one of the franchise's most enduring figures. While multiversal storytelling always leaves the door open for unexpected revivals, Atwell has shifted her focus toward other major Hollywood projects, including starring alongside Tom Cruise in the *Mission: Impossible* franchise. Whether Marvel decides to bring back Peggy Carter in a proper capacity remains to be seen, but Atwell clearly prefers her hero to stay standing next time.