Dancing With the Stars Ringer Debate: Jenna Dewan & More Face Unfair Advantage Claims

The debate over trained performers dominating *Dancing With the Stars* is practically a ballroom tradition. Across multiple seasons of the hit ABC reality competition, famous contestants like Jenna Dewan, Heather Morris, Jordan Fisher, and Melissa Rycroft have drawn massive side-eye for entering the cast with extensive background training already on their resumes. For many viewers, seeing a celebrity who already knows how to hit an eight-count takes away from the classic transformation narrative. While impressive footwork yields high scores, it routinely sparks uproar among fellow cast members and viewers alike. The discourse reached a boiling point back in 2009 during Season 8, when long-time pro Maksim Chmerkovskiy publicly voiced his frustration over what he viewed as a fundamentally unfair competition structure.

Watch

Clips tied to this story.

▶Watch on YouTube

During that 2009 run, Chmerkovskiy was paired with Hollywood actress Denise Richards. He openly called out contestant Melissa Rycroft, noting her extensive history with classical ballet and her time performing as an official Dallas Cowboys Cheerleader. Chmerkovskiy insisted he was merely saying what everyone else in the ballroom was thinking privately, declaring that seasoned pros could not reasonably go toe-to-toe with contestants holding years of pre-existing dance education. Fellow pro dancer and current *Dancing With the Stars* co-host Julianne Hough also noted the undeniable skill gap at the time. While Hough stopped short of calling the casting setup unfair outright, she admitted that the difference in baseline ability between experienced dancers and total beginners was strikingly obvious on the dance floor.

BUZZBEAT

Rycroft and her pro partner, Tony Dovolani, pushed back hard against the harsh backlash during their season. The former *The Bachelor* standout defended her place in the cast by pointing out that she was hardly the first contestant to step onto the floor with prior experience. Rycroft argued that her past background was not giving her the easy pass viewers assumed, maintaining that learning ballroom choreography still required intense labor regardless of her history. The debate has reemerged with nearly every cycle of the hit franchise. Whether it is Jenna Dewan showing off her routine, Heather Morris taking the stage, or Broadway talent Jordan Fisher dominating the leaderboard, the discussion never truly dies. Despite the recurring drama, producers continue to mix seasoned performers alongside complete novices, keeping the longstanding ringers debate alive and kicking.