Julia Stiles, Harry Shum Jr., Jenna Dewan and Carrie Ann Inaba
Reality TV

Carrie Ann Inaba Tackles 'DWTS' Ringer Controversy Following Season 35 Cast Reveal

The long-serving judge addresses fan frustration over celebrities entering the ballroom with prior dance backgrounds.

By Rae MitchellPublished Updated 2 min read

Every single season of *Dancing With the Stars* brings two guarantees: sparkles and outrage over ringers. Following the official cast reveal for Season 35, the eternal debate over contestants entering the competition with prior dance experience has erupted once again among the show's dedicated fanbase. Now, veteran judge Carrie Ann Inaba is weighing in to share her perspective on whether trained performers really hold an unbeatable advantage on the ballroom floor. Viewers routinely take to social media after cast announcements to point out celebrities who already possess background training in jazz, ballet, or stage performance. For many fans, watching a former pop icon or Broadway veteran compete against a complete novice feels like an unfair matchup from night one. The primary concern among critics is that seasoned performers secure high scores early on, leaving true beginners struggling to catch up in the standings.

does dance experience give dwts contestants an unfair advantage Addressing the fan pushback, Carrie Ann Inaba weighed in on the delicate balance between natural rhythm and strict ballroom technique. While a background in movement can help a celebrity master complex choreography quickly, judges frequently point out that specialized ballroom styles require an entirely different discipline. Trained dancers often have to unlearn years of posture and habits that do not translate to traditional Latin or ballroom steps. Inaba has spent decades on the judging panel evaluating every category of contestant, from professional athletes to reality TV personalities. Her latest comments remind audiences that emotional connection, performance quality, and growth over time play just as big a role in winning the Mirrorball Trophy as technical precision.

Julia Stiles, Harry Shum Jr., Jenna Dewan and Carrie Ann Inaba
Julia Stiles, Harry Shum Jr., Jenna Dewan and Carrie Ann Inaba

who is in the dancing with the stars season 35 cast The conversation surrounding ringers is nothing new for the long-running competition series. Throughout the show's history, several eventual champions entered the ballroom with minimal background knowledge and managed to defeat early frontrunners through fan support and dramatic weekly improvements. As anticipation builds for the new season, the debate highlights the central tension that keeps viewers tuning in year after year. Whether fans cheer for the underdog or root for the top-tier performer, all eyes will be on the judges' table when the fresh batch of celebrities hits the dance floor.

The photos · 6

Julia Stiles, Harry Shum Jr., Jenna Dewan and Carrie Ann Inaba
Inaba (pictured last week) argued that it’s “difficult” to train for ballroom dance when you have experience in other styles like hip-hop or jazz.
“It takes a lot of time to un-train the body to put your weight on the front more over your toes instead of back and down and grounded,” she noted. “It’s not as easy as people think.”
Inaba was specifically asked about Jenna Dewan (pictured here), Harry Shum Jr. and Julia Stiles, whose castings have caused some debate.
They “have an advantage in some ways,” Inaba admitted. (Pictured: Harry Shum Jr. for “DWTS.”)
She argued though, that “it’s been a few years since they’ve all danced.” (Pictured: Shum Jr. with his pro partner Jenna Johnson.)

More like this

Get the pop news brief

One daily email. The biggest celebrity, music and TV stories, no filler.

Reader reaction

Loading comments…

People also ask

Why are DWTS fans upset about the Season 35 cast?
Many viewers feel that celebrities with prior dance or stage experience have an unfair edge over complete beginners in the competition.
What did Carrie Ann Inaba say about contestants with dance experience?
The veteran judge addressed the ongoing debate by explaining how specialized ballroom techniques differ from other dance disciplines, requiring even experienced stars to learn new skills.