Mariah Carey Beats Brother's $20 Million Defamation Lawsuit Over Tell-All Memoir

Mariah Carey is officially closing the book on an exhausting family courtroom saga. A New York judge has tossed out the multimillion-dollar defamation complaint brought by her brother, Morgan Carey, putting an end to a high-stakes clash sparked by the pop icon's candid 2020 autobiography. Morgan had sued his superstar sibling for damages topping $20 million following the release of *The Meaning of Mariah Carey*. In his initial May 2021 filing, he alleged that the chart-topping diva smeared his name and wrecked his personal reputation by describing him as an aggressive figure and suggesting he had engaged in illegal narcotics trade during their youth. In court documents, Morgan maintained that he initiated the litigation out of grief and deep disappointment rather than spite, insisting he felt no jealousy toward his sister's legendary career.

Watch

Clips tied to this story.

▶Watch on Instagram

The court determined that Morgan failed to meet the rigorous legal standard required to keep the action alive. In a decision delivered by New York State Supreme Court Justice Leslie A. Stroth, the court ruled that the plaintiff did not adequately establish that the Grammy-winning icon acted with "actual malice" when sharing her personal memories in the book. To move forward with defamation claims in cases involving public interest or high-profile publications, plaintiffs must demonstrate that the author knowingly fabricated details or proceeded with reckless indifference to the truth. Justice Stroth concluded that Morgan's arguments did not satisfy that demanding bar, bringing the nearly five-year legal headache to a decisive halt.

BUZZBEAT

Released in autumn 2020, *The Meaning of Mariah Carey* offered fans an unfiltered journey through the singer's turbulent childhood, rise to global superstardom, and complex familial relationships. Carey pulled no punches while recounting painful early memories, including frightening confrontations and domestic friction involving her older siblings before her talent propelled her to international fame. Morgan had fiercely disputed multiple passages, arguing that the portrayals painted an unfair and damaging picture of his character. However, with the judge's formal dismissal, the superstar can permanently leave the bitter legal showdown behind and keep her focus firmly on her creative empire.